Namaz k bad aik hi Awaz k sath Ijtamai Dua


Question :
Hamari basti mein 2 jamaten hain' jin mein sy her aik raah sawab per hony ki madi hai' in mein sy aik jamat namaz khatam hony k bad hath utha ker ijtamai tour per youn dua kerti hai k:

Aur is tarha aik aur dua bhi parhty hain' jissy dua fatiha kaha jata hai jab k dosri jamat yh kehti hai k salaam pherny k bad hum is tarha nahi karen gay jis tarha pehli jamat ny kia hai. is silsila mein hum jab pehli jamat sy pochty hain to woh kehti hai k yh ijtamai dua kamal namaz hai aur yh dua hi to hai' is mein siwaye kher-o-bhalai k aur kuch nahi lekin dosri jamat is k bary mein yh kehti hai k yh bidat hai Qk Nabi kareem S.A.W sy yh sabit nahi hai aur yh jamat Nabi S.A.W k irshad

Muslim no. 1718.
sy bhi apny muaqaf ki taed mein estadlaal kerti hai....... hum nojawan preshan hain aur hum nahi janty k in mein sy kon si jamat raah-e-rast per hai' lehaza app sy Aye Brotheran! mutalba yh hai k wazeh farmayen k inmein  sy kon si jamat raah rast per hai?

Answer :
Imam k salaam pherny k bad aik hi awaz mein ijtamai dua k bary mein humen koi aisi daleel maloom nahi jo is ki mashroyet per dalalat kerti ho. is silsila mein bahos alilmiya wal ifta ki fatwa committee ki tarf sy pehly aik fatwa sadir ho chuka hai jo k hasb-e-zail hai:
"Farz namazo k bad hath utha ker dua kerna sunnat nahi hai khuwah akela imam dua kery ya muqtadi ya donu mil ker balky yh bidat hai Qk yh Nabi kareem S.A.W sy sabit hai na Hazraat sahaba karaam R.A. sy. hath uthaye bagair dua kerny mein koi harj nahi Qk baz ahaadis mein is ka ziker majod hai. Wa Billah Al tufeeq."
Darood-e-pak
Fatwa Committee



Tags : namaz, prayer, dua, supplication, ijtamai, unison
 
 

This question is on 416 page in Fatawa Islamiyah book.


Book Publisher Saudi Arab

http://www.dar-us-salam.com/
POBOX: 11416 Saudi Arab
Phone: 0096614043432
Email: riyadh@dar-us-salam.com
Book Publisher Pakistan

http://www.darussalampk.com/
36 Lower Mall, Lahore
Phone: 00924237324034 Email:info@darussalampk.com