Jis hujrah mai Qabren houn' us mai namaz jaiz nahi


Question :
Mai ny in baz logo sy jhagrah kia jo qabristan mai namaz k jawaz ka fatwa daity hain aur is masjid mai bhi namaz parhna jaiz qarar daity hain jis mai qabr ya qabren houn. mai ny sahi aur sureeh ahaadis k sath in k shubhat ka rad kia lekin inhuny mery jawab mai yh kaha k jab Rasool Allah (S.A.W)' Hazrat Aisha R.A. k ghar mai dafan huway to phir woh kahan namaz parhti theen? sawal yh hai k kia app ki qabr sharif Hazrat Aisha R.A. k ghar k ander thi ya bahir? naiz inhuny yh bhi kaha k Rasool Allah (S.A.W) aur Sahaba karam R.A. ny masjid haram mai bhi namazen parhi hain halankey wahan Hazrat Ibrahim A.S. ki zoja Saiydah HAzir R.A. aur baz anmbiya madfon hain' to kia in ki yh bat sahi hai k Hazrat Aisha R.A.' Rasool Allah (S.A.W) ki tadfeen k bad hujrah mai namaz parhti rahen aur masjid haraam mai Hazrat Hajir R.A. aur baz anmbiya karam A.S. ki qabren hain?

Answer :
Hazrat Aisha R.A.sy ravayat hai k Rasool Allah (S.A.W) ny apny marz almout mai farmaya:
Allah Ta'ala yahod-o-Nasara per la'anat farmaye k inhuny apny nabiyo ki qabro ko masjiden bana lia tha.
"Allah Ta'ala yahod-o-Nasara per la'anat farmaye k inhuny apny nabiyo ki qabro ko masjiden bana lia tha."
Al-Bukhari no. 1330 and Muslim no. 531.
Hazrat Aisha R.A. biyan farmati hain:
App (S.A.W) k is biyan farmany ka maqsad yh tha k app apni ummat ko aisa kerny sy dara rahy thy' ager yh bat na hoti to app ki qabr ko bhi numaya kia jata lekin app ny is bat ko napasand farmaya k apko qabr ko masjid banaya jaye.
"App (S.A.W) k is biyan farmany ka maqsad yh tha k app apni ummat ko aisa kerny sy dara rahy thy' ager yh bat na hoti to app ki qabr ko bhi numaya kia jata lekin app ny is bat ko napasand farmaya k apko qabr ko masjid banaya jaye."
Sahih Bukhari no.1330 aur Sahih Muslim no. 529. 531.
Aik ravayat mai hai:
App is bat daray k app ki Qabr ko masjid bana lia jaye.
"App is bat daray k app ki Qabr ko masjid bana lia jaye."
Bukhari ki ravayat mai ilfaz yh hain:
Mai is bat sy darta hoon k k meri qabr ko masjid na bana lia jaye.
"Mai is bat sy darta hoon k k meri qabr ko masjid na bana lia jaye."
Al-Bukhari no. 1330.
In ahaadis sy maloom howa k qabron per bani howi masjido mai namaz parhna najaiz aur inhen banana haram hai. Sawal mai saiil ny jo yh pocha hai k RAsool Allah (S.A.W) k Hazrat Aisha R.A. k ghar mai madfon huny k bad Hazrat Aisha R.A. namazen kaha parha kerti theen? aur kia apki qabr ghar k ander thi ya bahir? to is ka jawab yh hai k HAzrat Aisha R.A. hi in sahi ahaadis ki ravi hain' jin mai Rasool Allah (S.A.W) ny qabro ko masjiden banany sy mana farmaya hai aur yh bhi Allah Ezz-o-Jal ki hikmat-o-maslehat hai k in ahadis ki ravi Hazrat Aisha R.A. hain lehaza is sy maloom howa k woh is hujrah mai qatan namazen na parhti theen' jin mai qabren theen Qk ager woh is hujrah mai namaz parhteen to in ahaadis ki mukhalfat lazim aati' jinhen inhuny khud Rasool Allah (S.A.W) sy ravayat kia hai aur yh app k shayan-e-shan na tha. Baki rahi yh bat k Hazrat Hazir R.A. ya baz Anmbiya masjid haram mai madfon hain' to is ki koi daleel nahi hai.
Fatwa Committee



Tags : namaz, pray, qabaristan, graveyard
 
 

This question is on 78 page in Fatawa Islamiyah book.


Book Publisher Saudi Arab

http://www.dar-us-salam.com/
POBOX: 11416 Saudi Arab
Phone: 0096614043432
Email: riyadh@dar-us-salam.com
Book Publisher Pakistan

http://www.darussalampk.com/
36 Lower Mall, Lahore
Phone: 00924237324034 Email:info@darussalampk.com